Bitbucket vs GitHub: DevOps tools comparison

Picture: kavzov/Adobe Inventory
Tech leaders perceive that code is vital to how companies function, and that it constitutes a few of a company’s most necessary mental property. Within the previous days, a code repository was largely simply the place you saved your code; immediately, code repositories are the middle of a bigger DevOps software resolution that impacts how your staff works. Two of the most effective identified DevOps instruments obtainable are Atlassian’s Bitbucket and Microsoft’s GitHub.

What’s Bitbucket?

Should-read developer protection

Bitbucket is a model management system. Atlassian’s Bitbucket grew up within the enterprise with a give attention to non-public repositories and self-hosted choices for professionals. Initially supporting each distributed and centralized model management architectures, lately Bitbucket has dropped assist for any centralized model management choice to focus solely on Git.
Fashionable options of Bitbucket embody:

Cloud safety
Code Evaluate
Greatest-in-class Jira integrations

What’s GitHub?

GitHub is a Git-based model management system constructed round the concept it needs to be straightforward to share and collaborate when writing software program. Although now owned by Microsoft, GitHub had its beginnings within the open supply group, the place it shortly turned the spine of the open-source motion.
Fashionable options of GitHub embody:

Constructed-in bug tracker
Safety scanning
Huge consumer group

SEE: Hiring kit: Python developer (TechRepublic Premium)

GitHub vs. Bitbucket: Characteristic comparability

Developer adoption

When selecting a code repository and model management system, it’s necessary to do not forget that it’s one half of a bigger DevOps tradition and that to achieve success it should should be embraced by your builders who will use it a number of instances per day — each day.
There isn’t a denying that builders have flocked to GitHub. It’s the usual if you wish to host an open supply venture and be taken critically; over time, a developer’s GitHub account has change into a type of calling card.
Bitbucket has traditionally targeted on the enterprise, and a lot of the repositories are non-public. Atlassian boasts having over 10 million registered Bitbucket users, so the service does have a profitable observe document as properly.
Since GitHub and Bitbucket are based mostly on Git and the underlying rules of distributed model management, builders can decide each up shortly.
Backside line: In case you are working closely with open supply software program, GitHub is your finest guess; if not, and different options have you ever leaning in direction of Bitbucket, simply know not your entire builders might have used it earlier than – the reverse is probably going not the case.

Person interface

Each Bitbucket and GitHub have net interfaces and desktop shoppers. These interfaces assist every thing from branching and pull requests to merging and battle decision. Much like the feedback above, your growth staff can be utilizing these interfaces each day, so even small efficiencies can enhance productiveness and job satisfaction over time.
GitHub’s net interface tends to be a bit extra straight-forward than Bitbucket, however at instances you might want to know the underlying Git command construction. On the desktop, Atlassian’s Sourcetree permits you to clone a GitHub repository in case you are attempting to work in a number of repository environments. Sourcetree is among the cleanest consumer experiences for supply management in the marketplace.
SEE: Quick glossary: DevOps (TechRepublic Premium)
GitHub has an official mobile app, whereas Bitbucket cell apps are created by third-parties. That stated, each GitHub and Bitbucket have an online interface that’s fairly cell pleasant.
One space the place GitHub stands out is with its built-in situation tracker, aptly named GitHub Issues. The UI permits builders to trace and handle bugs whereas they work with the code. Bitbucket has some comparable performance, nevertheless it’s not as sturdy with out Jira integration.
Backside line: Each GitHub and Bitbucket are pretty evenly matched on the consumer interface entrance. In the event you’re not utilizing different Atlassian merchandise as a part of your DevOps software chain (e.g., Jira or Trello), GitHub’s situation tracker may give it a slight edge.


Your DevOps pipeline must assist your efforts on the safety entrance, testing, venture administration, collaboration and steady supply. This happens by way of a mix of first- and third-party integrations, in addition to the power to customise workflows and internet hosting flexibility. GitHub doesn’t assist native internet hosting, so in case you have safety or regulatory necessities that mandate you to self-host wholesale, Bitbucket is your new finest pal.
In relation to customizing workflows, GitHub presents GitHub Actions, whereas Bitbucket supplies Bitbucket Pipelines. Each are highly effective choices that mean you can transfer a few of your DevOps duties out of the area of specialists and into the arms of your builders. The most important areas the place the 2 DevOps instruments differ are conditionals and artifacts. Bitbucket conditionals are restricted to file adjustments, whereas GitHub’s extra versatile resolution permits you to write conditional statements. With regard to storing artifacts, GitHub has a way more beneficiant retention coverage.
SEE: Hiring kit: JavaScript (TechRepublic Premium)
Because it pertains to exterior integrations, Bitbucket’s marketplace is spectacular. For the reason that Microsoft acquisition, GitHub has made strides with its own marketplace as properly, nevertheless it feels much less mature. Bitbucket integrates seamlessly with different Atlassian merchandise, together with Jira, Trello and Confluence, that are three of the most well-liked instruments used within the enterprise as a part of the DevOps software chain.
In case your group is doing agile software program growth, there’s a actually good likelihood you’re utilizing Jira. The worth of the tight integration that Bitbucket has with Jira can’t be understated. The Atlassian software suite is extremely mature within the enterprise, and these are wealthy, full-featured purposes on their very own. Whereas code opinions, situation monitoring, and venture administration performance could also be higher in GitHub if you end up simply evaluating GitHub to Bitbucket, if you evaluate Bitbucket and the Atlassian software suite to simply the performance in GitHub, you’ll discover a large hole that may’t be plugged proper now by the integrations GitHub presents.
Backside line: In the event you’re already utilizing some or the entire Atlassian software suite as a part of your present workflow, Bitbucket will amplify the worth you’re getting from that funding. Equally, when you want a self-hosted resolution, Bitbucket has you lined.


Price is all the time an element when selecting software program, however if you end up selecting software program that requires per-seat licensing, it may be much more necessary. Each GitHub and Bitbucket provide three tiers of assist, together with a free choice to get began. Whereas the primary two tiers are pretty comparable in value, GitHub is kind of a bit costlier at that third tier: $21 per month/user vs Bitbucket’s $6 per month/user.
Our take — value isn’t every thing, so spend time understanding the options earlier than simply signing up for the most cost effective resolution.

Last ideas

As with most selections, what’s finest for you and your group will not be what’s finest for everybody. In relation to selecting a model management resolution, wanting on the entire product and the way it integrates into your present DevOps resolution is essential. Price is all the time an element, however you must also take into account how a lot your success is dependent upon the open supply group, setup time for brand spanking new hires and any safety or regulatory elements which can be distinctive to your enterprise.
Bear in mind, if all else fails: Ask your builders!

Source link